Judge, 1931-01-17 · page 8 of 48
Judge — January 17, 1931 — page 8: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
# "Kibitzers in History" - Judge Magazine Satire This page satirizes armchair strategists and backseat commanders throughout history. The top cartoon shows someone offering unsolicited advice to historical figures (Alexander, Plato, Hannibal, Caesar) about military campaigns—suggesting their famous strategies were actually flawed. The bottom cartoon depicts men in what appears to be a WWI-era hospital or military shelter (marked "NO SMOKING"), with the caption "His appendix is okay—I told you it was nerves, Tom!" This mocks civilians pretending to be medical experts, confidently diagnosing conditions they're unqualified to assess. The right-side quotes continue the theme: various "kibitzers" (unsolicited advisers) offer contradictory wisdom about careers and life choices, all equally presumptuous and unhelpful. The satire targets human tendency to give confident advice outside one's expertise.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
JUDGE Kibitzers in History ° \ ; | “VV 217 4 minate, Alexander, Let . | | big mistake if you ' route to Persia. You want to take a ie ae detour around Africa. You'll never — n empire the way you're g me tell you you'll be making a L, ake that Northern «\b conquer ing at it. “No, Plato, the stuff you're writing won't go over with the public. You want to j it up a little, tal advice. You'll be forgotten the after tomorrow if you turn out d philosophy like that. I'm tellin now.” my Take a tip, Hannibal and get over that phoney i f making a name for yourself by going around by I and coming down into the Roman pire over the Alps. That scheme all wet, and the elephants couldn't stand it. Let me give you the dope: il across to Ita nean from Afric famous.” y over the Mediter- you'll become “Now liste . Cesar, don't try to roads into Gaul and F at won't get you any- where. You'll be killed by those ics the minute you show your head. “Tm taking all teenty dresses, 1 climate. dear—anything to help this awful in a ge Julius. That's ny advi “Say, Leonardo, you may get a kick out of fooling around with a mess of paint but it isn’t going to get you anywhere, Why don't you get a good job making shoes? | “Bill, you're not going to make a little village li ford-on-Avon, are you, to go and live in some London Let me wise you up. You chance of crashing the London stage with guys like Marlowe and Beaumont and Fletcher around with all the contracts sewed up.” sap of yoursel ve a nice pretty SMOKING Soveter no- | S We “Them’s high-sounding — military theories you've got, Napoleon, only there's just one thing wrong with ‘em. They ain't practical. You try to pull 1 those maneuvres and you'll be smeared in no time at all. You're not cut out for army life anyhow. You're too little.” “Listen to me, Ben, they'll run you in the bughouse if you go flying that kite in rainstorms any more. This electricity racket is a lot of hooey. Take my advice and stick to the Franklin Stove. “His appendix is okay—I told you it was nerves, Tom!” —Parke Cumines 6 comicbooks.com